Mark Byrnes

Is Europe's newest tallest building "egomaniacal architecture" at its worst?

The Shard, Europe's newest tallest building, will be inaugurated today whether Londoners like it or not. And many Londoners do truly dislike it. The Guardian's Simon Jenkins wrote:

This egomaniacal architecture echoes the tower's political backers, Ken Livingstone, John Prescott and Boris Johnson, who equate phallic prominence with civic prowess. They are in thrall to the Shard's Qatari financiers.

Cities' own Feargus O'Sullivan took to Twitter to say he hopes the Shard will one day be seen as a sobering mistake, like Paris's Tour Montparnasse.

Not everyone in the city hates it. Architecture writer James Russel wrote in Bloomberg that "[t]he Shard isn’t good enough to quiet the tower haters, but its best moments point the way to tall building design that can gracefully coexist with the city’s invaluable history." Perhaps The Guardian's Steve Rose has the most thoughtful view of the new building, writing:  

It's difficult to deny that the Shard is out of scale with the low-rise streets around it, or that it ruins the view of St Paul's Cathedral from Parliament Hill. But then London has never been a precious, historic jewel of a city like Venice or Paris: it has grown haphazardly, been scarred by war and fire, and has continually overwritten its own history.

Parisians joke that the viewing deck of Tour Montparnasse offers the city's best views, views blissfully free of the Tour Montparnasse itself. When the Shard's viewing deck opens next February, it will provide similar relief (though it will be very expensive - $38.83 for adults, $29.49 for children). In the meantime, the BBC was able to show its viewers what people on the 69th floor will see.

On a recent trip to London, I took took some photos of the Shard. Some were accidental - its presence is hard to avoid, even from distant points throughout Central London. It certainly struggles to blend seamlessly with its more historic surroundings, but it commands attention. And if nothing else, has given London another unmistakable architectural symbol.

Here, we see the aesthetic clash of historic and new that has left many upset with the Shard's presence among its neighbors. 
An up-close look at the Shard from the ground level next to London Bridge Station.
A more basic, rectangular appendage as part of the iconic glass pyramid.
This angle shows remarkable similarities to Manhattan's One Bryant Park tower (completed in 2009).
An architectural contrast that, to its detractors, may be seen as Arab Money v. English Tradition. While it was financed by Qataris, many materials used are German and Dutch, the architect is Italian, and the property company, British.
A more contextual view of the severe contrast between old and new.
Directly across the Thames, two humbler office towers sandwich a view of the Shard.
The Tate Modern and Millenium Bridge along the Thames with the Shard lurking in the background.

All images courtesy author

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Equity

    How Poor Americans Get Exploited by Their Landlords

    American landlords derive more profit from renters in low-income neighborhoods, researchers Matthew Desmond and Nathan Wilmers find.

  2. An illustration of a private train.
    Transportation

    Let’s Buy a Train

    If you dream of roaming the U.S. in a your own personal train car, you still can. But Amtrak cuts have railcar owners wondering if their days are numbered.

  3. A Mormon temple with two spires, at dusk.
    Design

    Understanding the New Mormon Temple in Rome

    Despite its olive trees and piazza, the new temple will look familiar to American eyes.

  4. A photo of the interior of a WeWork co-working office.
    Design

    WeWork Wants to Build the ‘Future of Cities.’ What Does That Mean?

    The co-working startup is hatching plans to deploy data to reimagine urban problems. In the past, it has profiled neighborhoods based on class indicators.

  5. Solar panels on the tiled roof of a two-story house.
    Environment

    Solar Batteries Are Winning Over German Homeowners

    Solar home storage has morphed from a niche product in Germany to one with enormous mainstream potential.