One designer thinks his version of the notorious 1972 subway map wouldn't bother as many New Yorkers.

There's no transit map in North America as polarizing as the one Massimo Vignelli made more than 40 years ago for New York City. MTA riders say it was confusing. Designers say it may have just been too beautiful for this world. 

Max Roberts, a subway map enthusiast who has designed nearly a dozen unofficial MTA diagrams in recent years, thinks he's come up with a compromise:

(Max Roberts)

His latest concept is filled with many of the familiar elements found in Vignelli's map; geometric-looking boroughs, tightly kerned Helvetica, and clusters of straight lines that rub up against each other. But it also represents the subway routes and surrounding landscape more accurately. "No diagram map comes close to this one in terms of geographical reality," Roberts tells us.  

It's doubtful the opinionated Vignelli would necessarily approve. Years after his maps were pulled down from New York's subway cars in 1979, Vignelli, who died earlier this year, still found his creation to be near perfect. A 2008 compromise (used by the MTA to provide service update info online) by his firm added Staten Island and made the water blue instead of brown. Roberts was unimpressed with those changes. "The attempts to make it more geographical kill the power and simplicity of the original 1972 version and over compensate," he says. "Lower Manhattan is just as wrong as before, but now with extra bends."

Vignelli's 1972 (left) and 2008 (right) designs. (MTA)

His response does break a bit with Vignelli's vision, though, displaying water as blue—even bluer than that compromise map, actually—and greenspace as green. He also addresses the biggest hangup among those who disliked the '72 design: Station locations and line trajectories that didn't match up with reality.

Roberts used city street maps to figure out how to accurately place stations while still maintaining legibility. As for the subway paths, Roberts believes that 45-degree angles (as seen in Vignelli's 1972 and 2008 maps) don't quite work for New York because the broad line trajectories are usually steeper, or shallower. Instead, his map uses 30- and 60-degree angles. 

Roberts's solutions aside, the fact that map lovers and transit fans are still so passionate about a 40-year old design that only saw a few years of use speaks to the lasting power of Vignelli's approach. Joel Street, trying to figure out the "Vignelli conundrum" in the most recent issue of The American Reader thinks that, as bothersome as its abstraction is to so many, the average straphanger may be closer to accepting it than before. "As we interact with increasingly abstract technology, with its swipes and pinches, cuts and pastes," writes Street, "the colorful, angular world of the Vignelli map will start to seem less strange, and new maps of every sort may mirror its aesthetic merits without stirring discomfort in newer generations."

Channeling his inner Vignelli, Roberts feels quite satisfied with the final product. "If a user can cope with the 4/5/6 zig-zag at Park Avenue/Lexington Avenue being straightened out," says the University of Essex lecturer, "there should be nothing to object to here, anywhere."

 

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Young students walking towards a  modern wood building surrounded by snow and trees
    Environment

    Norway’s Energy-Positive Building Spree Is Here

    Oslo’s Powerhouse collective wants buildings that make better cities in the face of climate change.

  2. A photo of shoppers in the central textile market of downtown Jakarta.
    Design

    How Cities Design Themselves

    Urban planner Alain Bertaud’s new book, Order Without Design, argues that cities are really shaped by market forces, not visionaries.

  3. The Metropolitan Opera House in New York
    Equity

    How Urban Core Amenities Drive Gentrification and Increase Inequality

    A new study finds that as the rich move back to superstar cities' urban cores to gain access to unique amenities they drive low-income people out.

  4. A photo of Andrew Field, the owner of Rockaway Taco, looking out from his store in the Rockaway Beach neighborhood of the Queens borough of New York.
    Life

    Tacos and Transit: Rate Your City

    From taco-rich San Diego to the tortilla wastelands of Boston, we asked you to grade U.S. cities on two critical metrics: Mexican food and public transportation.

  5. Maps

    Where There Are More Single Men Than Women

    Almost everywhere, actually—at least up until a certain age.