Reuters/China Daily

Traffic circles are great at preventing fatal wrecks. But what can be done about the crashes they do provoke?

Roundabouts are easy to love. They’re elegant in design, reduce traffic deaths compared to traditional intersections, and can support some gnarly public art.

But Americans hate them anyway, and one reason may be becoming clearer: While roundabouts are great at preventing serious crashes, they may bring on more non-fatal wrecks, to believe the latest in traffic-circle research coming from the fecund roundabout reserve of Wisconsin.

Past monitoring of 30 of the state’s 300-plus roundabouts revealed these particular intersections, which used to be traffic-signal controlled, experienced a 38 percent drop in car deaths and injuries. At the same time the total number of crashes jumped 12 percent. These additional accidents caused mainly property damage, and are thought to be a result of confused or unprepared drivers trying to navigate the unfamiliar roadway design.

Beau Burdett and other researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Madison have attempted to elucidate just what happens when a ride around the circle goes pear-shaped. They pored through six years of accident data from 53 Wisconsin roundabouts and found a couple of interesting patterns, which are described in the Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board (unfortunately behind a paywall).

Burdett and crew focused on crashes involving single vehicles—such as when somebody suddenly careens off the shoulder—which have an oddly high occurrence at roundabouts. Between 30 to 50 percent of accidents at single-lane roundabouts around the U.S. have involved lone vehicles. In the Wisconsin rotaries Burdett studied, they made up roughly 30 percent of crashes. Two of these were fatal, with one incident involving an impaired motorcyclist and another a driver tossed from a vehicle during foul weather.

Single-vehicle wrecks had a variety of causes, including drunk or distracted driving, poor road quality, animals in the road, slippery gravel, and motorists swerving to avoid other cars. But the biggest prompter of accidents was the weather, whether it be rain, snow, fog, or black ice. Weather accounted for more than a third of single-vehicle crashes, followed by impaired driving at 19 percent.

Burdett et al.

In terms of types of accidents, the vast majority (87 percent) were drivers gunning it off the road, more than half of which did so right as they approached a roundabout. As car buffs know, driving in a tight circle is a great way to test your vehicle’s lateral acceleration limits—or spin out. “The unique geometry and operating characteristics of a roundabout,” conclude the researchers, “compounded by impairment or weather conditions increased the likelihood of a run-off-road collision at a roundabout.”

None of these insights are meant to further demonize the already-polarizing roundabout, or deny its proven trauma-preventing, traffic-calming benefits. Some people (especially drunk ones) are just not very good at driving in a circle. But, as Burdett’s group notes, there “is still room for improvement.” They recommend that cities make roundabouts conspicuous well before drivers reach them, and by posting speed-limit signs to remind drivers that the laws of physics still apply within their circular confines. Another trick: landscaping the centers of roundabouts, which they say is an effective (and pleasing-to-the-eye!) way of grabbing motorists’ attention before they sail off the road.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A young girl winces from the sting as she receives the polio vaccine in 1954.
    Life

    How Mandatory Vaccination Fueled the Anti-Vaxxer Movement

    To better understand the controversy over New York’s measles outbreak, you have to go back to the late 19th century.

  2. Electricians install solar panels on a roof for Arizona Public Service company in Goodyear, Arizona.
    Environment

    A Bottom-Line Case for the Green New Deal: The Jobs Pay More

    A Brookings report finds that jobs in the clean energy, efficiency, and environmental sectors offer higher salaries than the U.S. average.

  3. Equity

    Is This the Next Mayor of Boston?

    City Councilor Michelle Wu, a Chicago native, has pushed for fare-free transit, tangled with Airbnb over housing regulations, and shaken up the politics of Old Boston.  

  4. A new map of neighborhood change in U.S. metros shows where displacement is the main problem, and where economic decline persists.
    Equity

    From Gentrification to Decline: How Neighborhoods Really Change

    A new report and accompanying map finds extreme gentrification in a few cities, but the dominant trend—particularly in the suburbs—is the concentration of low-income population.

  5. A crowded room of residents attend a local public forum in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
    Life

    Are Local Politics As Polarized As National? Depends on the Issue.

    Republican or Democrat, even if we battle over national concerns, research finds that in local politics, it seems we can all just get along—most of the time.