A clip charting the redevelopment of the city of Aylesbury shows its age.

Welcome to the latest installation of “Public Access,” where CityLab shares its favorite videos—old and new, serious and nutty—that tell a story about place.

How do you create modern facilities in a historic town? Judging by this 1972 film, a good idea might be to examine what England did in the small city of Aylesbury—and then do exactly the opposite.

This intriguing clip from British Pathé, designed to run in movie theaters before the main feature, explores what happened to the town 45 miles northwest of London in the 1960s and early ‘70s. Designated an “overspill town” by the Greater London Council, Aylesbury was expanded by official decree as part of a constellation of exurban satellites, intended to accommodate exiles from the capital in cities that lay beyond the greenbelt on which all construction was banned.

The results of this transformation shown in the film are grim—at least according to soon-to-be disgraced presenter Bill Grundy, whose career ended four years later after he actively encouraged the Sex Pistols to swear on live TV. According to Grundy’s version of Aylesbury’s transformation, historic streets in what was once a sleepy market town have been flattened with a vast load of cement, while an obtrusive, charmless Brutalist civic center towers over a  weathered roofscape.

Is this fair? Certainly the crystalline hulk of the civic center, comprising a town hall, library, and bus station, seems bulky and austere for its setting—as if the Eye of Sauron has relocated inappropriately to the cozy greenness of The Shires—but the film overstates its case. The creation of Aylesbury’s new civic center road system and housing did indeed entail some destruction of historic buildings that seems unforgivable in retrospect.

But a quick look of the map reveals that most new construction took place not over the old town, but on its edge—which is why the film has many old lanes to shoot from in order to provide contrast with the new construction.

Grundy’s critique is still fascinating because it shows how much attitudes have shifted since. He expresses heavy-handed loathing of the new buildings but grudgingly admits that, as a matter of planning, they do work. The new shopping street and mall are busy, while citizens traveling by bus along smoother, wider roads are fed effortlessly into the civic center’s amenities.

A contemporary architecture and planning enthusiast might come to the opposite conclusion. The spiky, interesting examples of Brutalism we see here could easily feature in a coffee table book today, even if the style and its chosen setting remain controversial. What the film grudgingly admires, meanwhile, seems appalling.

Like too many British towns, Aylesbury’s historic core is radically cut off from its residential hinterland by an inner beltway, creating a kind of rampart that privileges car access at the expense of placemaking. It’s a dispiriting environment which the pleasure of entering the narrower, older streets at the beltway’s heart never entirely dispels. Aylesbury is a fairly thriving city of just under 60,000 people now, but the effect of those planning flaws still endures—far more so than the jarring modernity of its 1960s buildings.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Design

    A History of the American Public Library

    A visual exploration of how a critical piece of social infrastructure came to be.

  2. Equity

    Berlin Builds an Arsenal of Ideas to Stage a Housing Revolution

    The proposals might seem radical—from banning huge corporate landlords to freezing rents for five years—but polls show the public is ready for something dramatic.

  3. Multicolored maps of Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Tampa, denoting neighborhood fragmentation
    Equity

    Urban Neighborhoods, Once Distinct by Race and Class, Are Blurring

    Yet in cities, affluent white neighborhoods and high-poverty black ones are outliers, resisting the fragmentation shown with other types of neighborhoods.

  4. A photo of a design maquette for the Obama Presidential Center planned for Jackson Park and designed by Tod Williams Billie Tsien Architects with Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates.
    Design

    Why the Case Against the Obama Presidential Center Is So Important

    A judge has ruled that a lawsuit brought by Chicago preservationists can proceed, dealing a blow to Barack Obama's plans to build his library in Jackson Park.

  5. a photo of a used needle in a park in Lawrence, Massachusetts.
    Equity

    Why the Rural Opioid Crisis Is Different From the Urban One

    As deaths from heroin, fentanyl, and prescription opioids soar in the U.S., a new study looks at the geographic factors driving the drug overdose epidemic.