As zany and unrealistic as his campaign is, the message is undeniably, brutally true.

Jimmy McMillan ... remember him? You know, the guy with the white wrap-around facial hair, gloves, and "The Rent is Too Damn High" message who made the 2010 New York State governor's campaign interesting, even funny. Who can forget that catchphrase, or those whiskers? Well, he’s back. He dropped a record late last month with an anthem themed around the same singular message of his earlier campaign. He's also contemplating a run for New York City mayor. McMillan was the brunt of plenty of jokes in 2010 and was a running gag on SNL. But he also raised a critical issue for most New Yorkers. Simply said, the rent was and is too damn high. As zany and unrealistic as his campaign is, the message is undeniably, brutally true.
According to The Elliman Report, which tracks real estate market trends in New York City, the average monthly rental price for a Manhattan apartment is now $3,930, up 3.7 percent from just 12 months ago. In Brooklyn, the average rent is now $2,971, up 11.5 percent over last year. And New York's vacancy rate is at an all-time low. Of the 165,000 "affordable" housing units built or preserved during Mayor Michael Bloomberg's tenure, "only about 8 percent were intended for households making less than 40 percent of the metropolitan area’s median income," according to The New York Times, "though they make up nearly one-third of all New York City households." And it is very likely that New York City tenants lucky enough to have rent stabilized apartments will see their rents go up as much as 9.5 percent this year. These are apartments supposedly designed for low-income families. A recent New York Observer story put it this way: "Low-Wage Jobs Are On the Rise In New York, But Where Can the Poorly Paid Afford To Live?"
As rents increase with the forward march of gentrification, it puts pressure on many New Yorkers. Areas such as Red Hook in Brooklyn or Long Island City in Queens used to have rents that, while a stretch, allowed working-class New Yorkers a home. Historian Josh Freeman tells us of a city that was designed for working-class New Yorkers to thrive ... in the 1950s and '60s. The development of rent controls, planning for affordable housing, and the creation of targeted development meant that even blue collar families with modest incomes could find a home. While rents and the cost of living have increased, poverty has concentrated in public housing projects and the surrounding neighborhoods. Now over 20 percent of all New Yorkers live below the poverty line.

This economic condition has forced families to move or double up. And it's no small coincidence that the city's homelessness rate has skyrocketed at the same time.
As Richard Florida has shown, New York City "ranks first among the 10 largest U.S. metros for its percentage of low-income households that are located in exclusively low-income census tracts (41 percent).” New York has become, even more than it already was, a class-divided city. 
This is beyond sad. There was a time when New York was a model for other cities in terms of housing policy. Urban historian Nicholas Bloom reminds us how Gotham once made room for all of its citizens, or at least it struggled to do so. 
Now, it appears that we are in free fall when it comes to rational housing policies. The result is a squeezing of our city.
Jimmy McMillan is unassailably right. While he will never be a serious candidate, others would be wise to adopt his issue and call. Without a legitimate policy debate, models, or plans that address or remedy this situation, New York might just rot from within.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A photo of a police officer in El Paso, Texas.

    What New Research Says About Race and Police Shootings

    Two new studies have revived the long-running debate over how police respond to white criminal suspects versus African Americans.

  2. Equity

    The Problem With Research on Racial Bias and Police Shootings

    Despite new research on police brutality, we still have no idea whether violence toward African Americans is fueled by racial prejudice. That has consequences.

  3. A map of Minneapolis from the late 19th century.

    When Minneapolis Segregated

    In the early 1900s, racial housing covenants in the Minnesota city blocked home sales to minorities, establishing patterns of inequality that persist today.

  4. photo: A protester stands on a damaged bus stop near the Third Police Precinct on May 28 in Minneapolis during a protest over the death of George Floyd.

    In Minneapolis Protests, Bus Drivers Take a Side

    The city’s transit union issued a statement of support for members who balked at assisting police during demonstrations over the killing of George Floyd.

  5. A map of population density in Tokyo, circa 1926.

    How to Detect the Distortions of Maps

    All maps have biases. A new online exhibit explores the history of map distortions, from intentional propaganda to basic data literacy.