Gustavo Petro was impeached after his recycling program failed. The move could very well stifle municipal innovation there.

Bogotá is an urban policy "miracle," moving from failure to case study in just 20 years. The Colombian capital has become known internationally for it innovative municipal initiatives prioritizing civic culture, public transportation, public spaces, and creative social programs. Bogotá's transformation has been led by strong figures like former Mayor Antanas Mockus, who mooned a university auditorium and invented traffic mimes and "violence vaccines." His successor, Enrique Peñalosa, is a public transportation champion who created the one of the world's largest Bus Rapid Transit systems.

So it's a strange state of affairs indeed that current Bogotá Mayor Gustavo Petro received a political "death sentence" last week: impeachment, courtesy Colombia Inspector General Alejandro Ordóñez, and a 15-year ban on holding public office after he botched the roll-out of an overhauled trash collection scheme that allegedly violated the country's commerce regulations.

Yes, Petro's sin was attempting to replace a private trash collection system with a public one. The organizing principle behind the scheme was to start formally paying the hundreds of indigent Bogotá families who make a living digging through garbage for recyclables. Alas, the program's implementation was a poorly orchestrated fiasco, and trash literally piled up in the streets over the first three days. According to the Inspector General, the mayor’s actions endangered the health of Bogotá's citizens. (For the sake of a health comparison, Madrid recently endured two weeks of a garbage collector strike.)

It’s worth noting that despite that bumpy start, a modified version of the original program, using both public and private companies, is now picking up Bogota’s trash. Clearly it’s not only about actual rubbish.

But, convoluted Colombian partisan politics aside, the fall-out from this episode could be important for Bogotá's future.

Public policy is not a hard science. It is, in many ways, about experimentation. Results are rarely clear-cut, programs succeed on some metrics but fail at others. Sadly, there are no silver bullets; most policies have incremental effects. They're not set in stone, either. They can be modified, improved or scrapped. It is hardly reasonable – nor institutionally feasible – to kick out a mayor every time a well-intentioned program fails to immediately have its intended impact.

Notably, the same inspector general also sanctioned Bogotá's previous mayor, Samuel Moreno, who has been accused on far more serious corruption charges. But in that case, Ordóñez barred Moreno from public office for only one year.

Petro is now in Washington, D.C., lobbying the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. In the past week, both the U.S. ambassador and the UN High Commissioner of Human Rights in Colombia voiced concern. The next step is a review by the Colombian Prosecutor General, who could overrule the decision. The appeals process will go on into the new year — Petro’s legal team has already filed over 500 complaints to the Constitutional Court.

Further muddying the situation, local election authorities on Wednesday announced a citizen referendum to recall the mayor. The new effort is not tied to Ordóñez's banning decree, and if the ban is upheld, a February recall vote won't matter. Still, if it does go ahead, at least it will be a chance for the citizens to make their own leadership choices, which is likely why Petro is now backing the notion of a referendum against himself.

If the dismissal is ultimately confirmed, the future of local government innovation in Bogotá is clearly in danger. It's too easy to imagine well-intentioned scenarios gone wrong: The construction of the next branch of the TransMilenio BRT might run over budget, social programs might not meet their targets. What if traffic mimes give children nightmares? Negative results should be debated by the public, pilloried in the press and evaluated at the polls. But they're also an inevitable part of improving a city.

Demonstrators protest against the decision to remove Petro from his post at Bogota's Bolivar Square. (John Vizcaino/Reyters)

Colombia reformed its political system in the late 1980s, allowing cities to elect their own mayors for the first time. Bogotá’s executive seat became the second most important electoral position in the country, after the presidency. It’s no coincidence that Bogotá’s transformation started soon after.

The tens of thousands of people gathered in Bogota’s central square protesting the inspector general's decision think that the man they elected to govern them deserves to stay. Many others feel that he doesn't. They should all get to choose their mayor and – barring illegal behavior – see them serve their full terms.

Top image: Demonstrators protest against the decision to remove Petro from his post at Bogota's Bolivar Square. The sign reads, "Toxic waste, not recyclable." (John Vizcaino/Reyters)

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Warren Logan

    A City Planner Makes a Case for Rethinking Public Consultation

    Warren Logan, a Bay Area transportation planner, has new ideas about how to truly engage diverse communities in city planning. Hint: It starts with listening.

  2. a photo of the Eiffel Tower with the words "Made for Sharing" projected on it

    How France Tries to Keep English Out of Public Life

    France has a long history of using official institutions to protect the French language from outside influence. Still, English keeps working its way in.

  3. a photo of the L.A. Metro Expo Line extension

    Why Can’t I Take Public Transit to the Beach?

    In the U.S., getting to the beach usually means driving. But some sandy shores can still be reached by train, subway, and bus.

  4. an aerial view of Los Angeles shows the complex of freeways, new construction, familiar landmarks, and smog in 1962.

    The Problem With Amazon’s Cheap Gas Stunt

    The company promoted its TV show The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel with a day of throwback 1959-style prices in Los Angeles. What could go wrong?

  5. Transportation

    CityLab University: Induced Demand

    When traffic-clogged highways are expanded, new drivers quickly materialize to fill them. What gives? Here’s how “induced demand” works.