Justus Radford, a student from Grover Cleveland High School, looks on during a rally and Buffalo schools boycott at City Hall in Buffalo, N.Y., Monday, May 16, 2011. Some parents in Buffalo kept their children out of class and gathered on the steps of City Hall to protest the city school system's low graduation rates and under performing schools. AP/David Duprey

How one of the city's biggest success stories went wrong.

In 1972, a group of parents in Buffalo, New York, filed a federal lawsuit to desegregate the city's public schools. A judge ruled in their favor; the city went on to become a national model for school integration.

But four decades later, that progress have been erased. According to the Buffalo News, 70 percent of public schools in the city are segregated (defined as 80 percent or higher minority or white enrollment), the same level as when the 1972 lawsuit was filed. Today, just 47 percent of public school students graduate.

How did this happen?

The school desegregation rules that went into effect in 1976 required that each school be made up of 30 to 65 percent non-white students.

The city achieved this by turning many of the district's schools (a third, by 1985) into magnets that would draw to children of all races. These new programs were so popular that only 15 percent of the 30,000 students being bused across the city resisted the integration efforts.

Buffalo's program was so successful that the New York Times hailed it as a "model for U.S." The article described Buffalo's desegregation efforts as a "velvet steamroller." Then-Arkansas Governor Bill Clinton eventually recruited Buffalo Public Schools Superintendent Eugene Reville to lead Little Rock's desegregation efforts.

United States Army Corps of Engineers hosts students from Niagara Falls High School, Niagara Falls, NY, Hutchinson Technical High School, City Honors, Tapestry Charter School, and the Charter School for Applied Technologies, February 26, 2014. (Flickr/BuffaloUSACE)

Buffalo's results were so good that the court lifted its mandate in 1987. Since then, most of the gains have fallen away.

The city's shifting demographics have played a big role. In 1972, 54 percent of the city's public school students were white. Today, just 22 percent are. And residents are living in an increasingly segregated city. One elementary school in predominately white South Buffalo is 82 percent white. Nearly every other school in the city has seen minority enrollment jump.

A demographic map of the City of Buffalo using 2010 Census data.  (Blue dots represents White population. Green represents Black population. Red represents Asian population. Orange represents Hispanic population. Brown represents Other/Multi-Racial). Courtesy University of Virginia's Cooper Center for Public Service.

The city has tried to limit the impacts of neighborhood segregation by enacting a "choice admissions policy." Parents can apply to send their children to any school in the city.

And there are some very good options. Some of the city's magnet schools have remained academically strong (last year, Newsweek ranked magnet school City Honors as the 22nd best public high school in the country). And the city is still coming up with new specializations. The most recent proposal, a school that partners with the Buffalo-Niagara Medical Campus, teaching science, technology, engineering and math to students grades 5 through 12 received federal funding and praise from Secretary of Labor Thomas Perez earlier this week.

But magnet schools helped accelerate the decline of "regular" schools, fostering a sense of second-class status among students who couldn't get into one of the specialized programs. "The minute you set up criterion schools, you create an environment in which middle class kids will do better," says Henry Louis Taylor, a professor at the Department of Urban and Regional Planning at SUNY Buffalo. This was even a problem 30 years ago, when one guidance director at a non-magnet school told the Times, sometimes "students come here feeling they're the rejects."

Charter schools, allowed in New York State since 2000, only add to these woes. When the State started accepting charter school applications, writer Jake Halpern warned that "given Buffalo’s demographics, many of these schools are bound to be self-segregated enclaves." That's exactly what has happened. According to the Buffalo News, minorities made up 99 percent or more of the students at five different charters in 2012.

As a result, parents are often competing for just a handful of spots at the city's best schools. At magnets like City Honors (where 66 percent of its students are white) most students test their way in with only a few lottery spots open to everyone else. That means few of Buffalo's most disadvantaged kids get the privilege of attending. Vice President of the District Parent Coordinating Council Sam Radford told WBFO in 2011, "because so many schools are persistently low achieving schools, any other school you want to move your child to is another persistently low achieving school, and all the good schools - they'll tell you, 'Oh, we ain't got no room.'"

McKinley Vocational High School in 2012 after its renovation and expansion. (Wikimedia Commons/D-Day)

Whether the city can reverse this trend is an open question. Since the turn of the century, it's spent $1.4-billion on a dramatic upgrade of all public school facilities in an effort to make them as architecturally and technologically savvy as their suburban competitors. But that's had little impact on the neighborhoods that host them, and in turn, it's done little to address the fundamental problems. "It failed because it was building-specific," says Taylor. "We need to realize there's an interactive relationship between schools and neighborhoods. If we fix the neighborhoods, people will want to live in them."

Taylor points to programs like HUD's "Choice Neighborhood Program" which bring public and private sector community leaders together to develop a comprehensive plan that addresses a neighborhood's struggling schools, distressed housing stock, safety, and lack of services all at once. Taylor even led up an effort to win a $30 million Choice Neighborhood grant for the area around the city's impovershed Perry Projects. It was rejected by HUD last month, but Taylor plans on fine-tuning the application and re-apply next year.

Solving an issue as complicated as public school integration in a city as impoverished and segregated as Buffalo will never be easy. But the city did (during arguably the most tumultuous period in its history) come up with a unique solution that, for a brief period, seemed to work but was ultimately flawed.

Meaningful change will require a serious and never-ending effort. As Judge Curtin told the Times in 1985 when asked if he was pleased with Buffalo's results, "the school system is like most things in life; it calls for attention all the time."

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A crowded room of residents attend a local public forum in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.

    Are Local Politics As Polarized As National? Depends on the Issue.

    Republican or Democrat, even if we battle over national concerns, research finds that in local politics, it seems we can all just get along—most of the time.

  2. A tent-like pavilion with a colorful stained-glass design in a cemetery at dusk.

    The New Art Galleries: Urban Cemeteries

    With their long-dead inhabitants remembered only foggily, historic cemeteries like Mount Auburn and Green-Wood use art to connect to the living.

  3. Equity

    What the Supreme Court Said About the 2020 Census Citizenship Question

    In oral arguments, conservative justices asked about data science, while liberals asked what the citizenship question was really for.

  4. A photo of shoppers on University Avenue in East Palo Alto, California, which is flanked by two technology campuses.

    An Island of Silicon Valley Affordability Says Yes to More Housing

    East Palo Alto is surrounded by tech riches, but that hasn’t necessarily helped longtime residents, who welcome a state law mandating zoning reform

  5. U.S. 2020 Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg speaks at the 2019 National Action Network National Convention in New York.

    Pete Buttigieg and the Police Department: Race Record Under Scrutiny

    After a speech surfaced with Pete Buttigieg saying "All Lives Matter" in 2015, racial issues in the South Bend police department, and Buttigieg's role in them, are being scrutinized.