Associated Press

A primer on the key issues Scots are weighing at the ballots today.

Today marks a potential, but unlikely, new chapter in Scotland's history. People 16 years of age and older living in Scotland will decide whether the north should go it alone or continue 300 years of somewhat happy unity with the rest of the U.K. Given the demographics of our readership, there's approximately a 98 percent chance that you're not eligible to vote in today's big referendum.

Still! As a politically engaged global citizen you will likely talk about it with your co-workers and peers, weighing your own country's historical struggle to become independent from the United Kingdom with the economic realities of a Scotland-U.K. split. To help you with those conversations, we've compiled a list of key issues Scots (as well as the multitude of non-Scots living in Scotland and therefore eligible to vote) should consider, and you should mention to sound well-informed.

North Sea Oil


The Basics: It's estimated that about 84 to 90 percent of the oil in the North Sea belongs to Scotland. Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond has said that the wealth from that oil would go into a fund that would pay for social welfare programs and schools. And for a while, that would work. But reports also show that the North Sea's oil reserves are getting tapped out. Wood Mackenzie, an oil and wood consultancy firm, estimated that production (and revenue) would decline by 2018.

At the same time, Scotland has other industries, including whisky, tourism and textiles. Banking would be part of the list, but several banks have hinted that they'd bail on an independent Scotland.

If you agree that it is Scotland's oil, and think the country will bounce back when its oil reserves eventually run low, then you should support independence.

If you think that betting the future of your economy on oil reserves that will eventually run dry is a bad idea (in this case, it is a bad idea) then you should not support independence.

Social Welfare


The Basics: Scotland is more liberal than the rest of England, and wants to drastically change its welfare system. Scottish nationalists have promised to raise the Carer's Allowance (for people who spend 35 hours a week caring for someone), raise the minimum wage and enact several other changes. As Scotland's housing minister Margaret Burgess put it, "Scotland is an enormously wealthy country, but for far too many people it simply does not feel like it."

The Better Together campaign released a report arguing that the proposed social welfare reforms would be too expensive. A less biased panel established by the Scottish government found that it might take until 2020 for Scotland to separate its welfare system from the rest of the United Kingdom, as a faster separation might disrupt payments to people.

Also worth noting: Scotland has received more benefits than it paid in taxes over the last generation.

If you are convinced that Scotland will be able to afford the reforms (even when North Sea oil revenues decline) and/or don't think that the more conservative British government should decide how Scots run their social welfare program then you should support independence.

If you don't support the social welfare changes, or are skeptical of how much it will cost Scotland, then you should not support independence.

The Pound


The Basics: Salmond wants to keep using the British pound, but all of the U.K.'s major political parties oppose a currency union. Kevin Dowd, a professor of finance and economics at Durham University, summarized the pros and cons of Scotland keeping the pound in an op-ed for City A.M., but the key point is that while Scotland can keep using the pound without England's permission, it would also have to accept the Bank of England's monetary policies throughout the British Isles. Also, Scotland's struggling banks would no longer be able to rely on the Bank of England if things get bad.

Another, less than ideal option, would be to use the Euro.

If you, like the Adam Smith Institute, think Scotland could "flourish by using the pound without permission," as The Guardian put it, then you should support independence.

If you don't, then you should not support independence.

Scottish Power Post-Independence

The Basics: Scotland would be a much smaller country than the United Kingdom population-wise, but it could also join the European Union. That's kind of silly — as Neil Irwin at The New York Times wrote:

Paradoxically, pro-independence Scots have argued that they will recapture some of the advantages of size by joining the European Union. It seems slightly bonkers for Scots to get so frustrated about ceding power to bureaucrats in London and turn immediately to bureaucrats in Brussels, but there it is."

If you prefer bureaucrats in Brussels (or, if joining the EU doesn't work, just in Edinburgh) then you should support independence.

If you prefer bureaucrats in London then you should not support independence.


The Basics: This one is simple. Scotland has a long history of trying to maintain its independence, a tradition that has been represented on both the big (have you seen Braveheart?) and small screen. That independent spirit is captured in this pro-independence ad:

If you think Scotland has an independent history and an independent culture that warrants an independent nation, then you should support independence.

If you think Scotland can still be culturally and historically independent without being a different country, then you should not support independence.

This post originally appeared on The Wire, an Atlantic partner site.


'Red Band Society' Tries Too Hard to Make Permanently Hospitalized Children Seem Fun

ISIS Members Arrested in Australia Were Plotting a Public Beheading

‘You’re the Worst’ Has Become the Surprise Comedy Hit of the Summer

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. a photo of a WeWork office building

    What WeWork’s Demise Could Do to NYC Real Estate

    The troubled coworking company is the largest office tenant in New York City. What happens to the city’s commercial real estate market if it goes under?

  2. Uber Eats worker

    The Millennial Urban Lifestyle Is About to Get More Expensive

    As WeWork crashes and Uber bleeds cash, the consumer-tech gold rush may be coming to an end.

  3. Design

    Charles Jencks and the Architecture of Compassion

    The celebrated architectural theorist, who died this week, left a down-to-earth legacy: thoughtfully designed buildings and landscapes for people with cancer.

  4. The Buoyant Ecologies Float Lab

    Designing the Floating Future

    A prototype in the San Francisco Bay is testing a vision for floating buildings built to withstand sea-level rise. And it’s distancing itself from some other utopian visions for floating cities.

  5. A man wearing a suit and tie holds an American flag at a naturalization ceremony.

    The New Geography of American Immigration

    The foreign-born population has declined in U.S. states that voted Democratic in 2016, and increased in states and metros that voted for Trump.