Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo (3rd R) arrives at the end of a demonstration called by the Union of French Jewish Students on January 10, 2015. REUTERS/Youssef Boudlal

You have to remember that the cable news network maintains a highly peripheral position in Europe.

Is Paris mayor Anne Hidalgo’s threat to sue Fox News “insane”?  It’s been less than 24 hours since a freezing-looking Hidalgo caused a media storm by promising to take the American news channel to court over its false assertions about the existence of Muslim-only “no-go zones” where Sharia law reigns supreme in the French capital.

Fox has already been both heavily ridiculed by France’s version of The Daily Show and pressed into releasing an apology. For Hidalgo, this doesn’t go far enough. “I think we’ll have to go to court, I think we’ll have to sue,” she told CNN’s Christiane Amanpour. “The image of Paris has been prejudiced, and the honor of Paris has been prejudiced.”

For Americans well used to the cable news network's famously tenuous grasp of reality, the idea of a lawsuit might seem a little bizarre. Given that the land of cheese-eating surrender monkeys has been so wholeheartedly defamed by Fox News in the past, isn’t it strange to take umbrage now?

Not necessarily. To ask why Paris is fighting back now when it’s rolled with punches in the past doesn’t take into account Fox News’s highly peripheral position in Europe. Over here, if Fox News is discussed at all, it’s generally within the rather smug, “Aren’t Americans crazy?” school of European journalism, whose subjects can range from bans on teaching evolution to the shudder-inducing idea of people spraying cheese out of a can. Rather than provoking, Fox News is one of those comforting touchstones that can be brought out to reassure Europeans that, although their societies may appear to have gone mad, they still have a way to go before they reach that. When Fox News’s negative reports actually register, they’ve mainly been treated more like being bitten by a flea than mauled by a dog.

Right now, things are different. As we all know, gunmen have been at large in Paris and across the Ile de France in recent weeks, leaving behind a horrific death toll. Parisians are genuinely, understandably shaken up by the arrival of daylight murder in humdrum everyday corners of the city. Fox News’s coverage may be laughable, but this was not the month to falsely state that everyday Parisians’ shops, homes and corner cafés are booby-trapped outposts for the Islamic State.

It’s worth going over the utter ridiculousness of the no-go zones that Fox News outlined. Included within their limits are streets like Rue Oberkampf, a packed restaurant and bar strip so overwhelmingly hipsterfied that it’s pronounced "over" on a weekly basis. The zones are also terrible news for British and Belgian visitors, given that they cover Paris’s extremely busy main arrival point from those countries, the Gare Du Nord.

This wasn’t even the first ridiculous Fox News no-go zone story this year, of course. Earlier this month, the cable news network summoned up the specter of equally imaginary British zones in Birmingham and London. So far, neither city has suggested suing, but then neither of them is reeling from a recent terrorist attack.

Beyond these zones’ essential flaw—they’re fictional—their invention shows an ignorance of how European urban geography works in the first place. While Western Europe is now making up for lost time, geographical social division in its cities has rarely been as intense as in the United States. Widespread social housing has ensured that inner cities have to an extent remained a checkerboard of wealth and poverty (something Paris is actively trying to maintain) even if these areas’ different classes are often foreigners to each other.

Thus the Charlie Hebdo assassins hail not from some far-flung project whose name might make the elite shudder. They come from Paris’s 19th arrondissement, home to large Muslim communities but also to the city’s new concert hall, the fast gentrifying fringes of the Canal St Martin and one of the city’s most popular, beautiful parks. It’s not that Fox News is drawing its boundaries wrong. The idea that threats are contained within a few easily marked streets is in itself ignorant.

Rising to this sort of provocation might seem to be overdoing things, not least because it’s not even clear that the city of Paris has a viable case to plead. Hidalgo’s promise still plays well with a local crowd that could do with some righteous distraction right now. It also gives her a chance to cut a statesman-like figure. Striking a careful balance, on Tuesday Hidalgo made it clear this was no anti-American crusade by posting a photo on Facebook of her hugging New York’s Mayor De Blasio, stating that “we’ll never forget that New York has a great mayor with a great heart.” Hidalgo’s case may end up frittering into nothing, but in Paris at least, taking on Fox News is a battle where the stakes are low.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. a photo collage of 2020 presidential candidates.

    Will Housing Swing the 2020 Election?

    Among Democratic candidates for president, the politics of America’s housing affordability crisis are getting complicated. Just wait until Trump barges in.

  2. A photo of an abandoned building in Newark, New Jersey.

    The 10 Cities Getting a Philanthropic Boost for Economic Mobility

    An initiative funded by Bloomberg Philanthropies, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and Ballmer Group focuses on building “pipelines of opportunity.”

  3. A person tapes an eviction notice to the door of an apartment.

    Why Landlords File for Eviction (Hint: It’s Usually Not to Evict)

    Most of the time, a new study finds, landlords file for eviction because it tilts the power dynamic in their favor—not because they want to eject their tenants.

  4. A house with a for sale sign.

    Why Are Zoning Laws Defining What Constitutes a Family?

    It’s wrong to exclude safe uses of housing because of who belongs to a household. Like family law, zoning ordinances should prioritize functional families.

  5. A cat lays flat on a bench at a park on the outskirts of Tokyo.

    Why Don't Americans Use Their Parks at Night?

    Most cities aren’t fond of letting people use parks after dark. But there are good lifestyle, environmental, and safety reasons to reconsider.