Boulevard Anspach in Brussels, where the pedestrian zone will be laid out. Michael Costa/Flickr

The city's car-free zone, as it is currently designed, will only displace traffic, not reduce it.  

When Brussels announced plans to pedestrianize a big chunk of its downtown last year, many people were thrilled. Beset with congestion problems, Belgium's capital can sometimes be a grimy, gridlocked mess. Supporters hoped that booting cars off the city's main boulevard axis could make the urban center a greener, cleaner, and more pleasant place to be. Fast-forward a year, however, and the plans have proven far more controversial than expected. The most vocal critics are not just car lobbyists and local businesses, but also pedestrian and cycling advocates. That's because these plans raise a question all pedestrianization must grapple with: It's all very well clearing cars off a few streets, but what happens in the city outside the designated zone?

Brussels' answer is disappointing. In fact, it sounds like it came from another decade entirely. The new pedestrian zone may double the center's car-free area, but as this image shows, it will be bounded by a circular road system that critics say will be a "mini ring", an inner alternative to the already snarled, poorly-planned beltway around the city center. As Brussels city blogger Laurent Vermeersch notes, the plan could transform "quiet residential streets into busy roads with two lanes of traffic in one direction." Vermeersch cites a local environmental organization's disapproval. "It will be a pedestrian area for car drivers," the organization said.

It gets worse. The city is also fielding plans to build four new subterranean parking lots just outside the pedestrian zone. One of these might be under the lovely Place du Jeu du Balle, an old square in a largely working class area that hosts the Brussels flea market. Not only would funneling cars into this area risk disrupting the market, it would threaten quality of life in Marolles, one the most densely populated and likable neighborhoods in inner Brussels—the sort of area pedestrian zones are set up to protect. Urbanism blogger Kwinten Lambrecht also points out that building the new garages could ensure that car dominance continues for decades. If the city is to recoup the construction costs, after all, it will need to ensure a steady stream of cars using the parking lots for some time to come.

The flea market at Place du Jeu du Balle. (Daniel Lobo on Flickr via CC License)

What makes this plan yet more short-sighted is that it comes just as the Brussels Region (a different body from the city) is planning 10,000 new park-and-ride places at suburban transit terminuses as a way of encouraging locals not to drive into town. If the right hand knows what the left hand is doing, it doesn't really seem to care.

To be fair to the city, none of this is a done deal. The plan is currently undergoing a public consultation before it can be implemented. Still, Brussels' struggle highlights the impasse that pedestrianization can bring. Banishing cars from an area is one thing, but if you don't take steps to reduce motor vehicles across a city as a whole, then you're not solving a problem.  You're just exporting it.  

Brussels may be under intense pressure to please pedestrian, motor and business lobbies all at once—but when residents are rejecting your pedestrian plan because they think it will damage the very element it was supposed to enhance, you know you've taken a false step.

Top image via CC License.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Environment

    A 13,235-Mile Road Trip for 70-Degree Weather Every Day

    This year-long journey across the U.S. keeps you at consistent high temperatures.

  2. Opponents of SB 50.
    Equity

    Despite Resistance, Cities Turn to Density to Tackle Housing Inequality

    Residential “upzoning” policies being adopted from Minneapolis to Seattle were once politically out of the question. Now they’re just politically fraught.

  3. Design

    In Paris, the Eiffel Tower Is Getting a Grander, Greener Park

    The most famous space in the city is set to get a pedestrian-friendly redesign that will create the city’s largest garden by 2024.

  4. A map of the money service-class workers have left over after paying for housing
    Equity

    Blue-Collar and Service Workers Fare Better Outside Superstar Cities

    How much money do workers have after paying housing costs? For working-class and service workers in superstar cities, the affordable housing crisis hits harder.

  5. Life

    Having a Library or Cafe Down the Block Could Change Your Life

    Living close to public amenities—from parks to grocery stores—increases trust, decreases loneliness, and restores faith in local government.