NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton (left) and MPD Chief Cathy Lanier. REUTERS

NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton and D.C. Police Chief Cathy Lanier disagree on marijuana and its relationship to violent crimes. Or do they?

With so many changes to marijuana laws going into effect across the United States over just the past couple of years—including decriminalization in some places, full legalization in others, and expanded medical marijuana access in many more—you might forgive police officials from expressing wildly differing feelings on the subject.

New York City Police Commissioner Bill Bratton, for example, is blaming weed for a 17 percent uptick in homicides over last year's numbers, and a 23 percent rise in shootings.

"In this city, people are killing each other over marijuana more so than anything that we had to deal with in the '80s and '90s with heroin and cocaine," Bratton said at a press conference Monday.

Marijuana was sort-of decriminalized in New York City late last year, when Bratton and Mayor Bill de Blasio announced they would "stop arresting people on low-level marijuana charges and issue them tickets instead," as the Daily News reported. So Bratton's seemingly sudden animus toward pot strikes a bit of a weird tone, and as Gothamist notes, New York has certainly seen darker days than these:

[Is this w]orse than when gang violence killed 523 people in upper Manhattan alone from 1983 to 1988? Worse than when more than half of 414 homicides catalogued between March and October of 1988 (we had a total of 328 in 2014) were deemed drug-related? Worse than 1990, when 2,245 people were murdered in New York City?

Meanwhile, in Washington, D.C., where a law legalizing possession of up to two ounces of marijuana went into effect last week, Metropolitan Police Chief Cathy Lanier told reporters at the American News Women's Club this week that pot users represented the least of the city's policing problems—even more so now that resources would not be spent arresting and jailing residents for possession. “All those arrests do is make people hate us,” she said.

Lanier characterized Washingtonians who would have previously been busted for possession as characteristically nonviolent, and noted that legal alcohol tends to create far more difficult situations for her officers. "Marijuana smokers are not going to attack and kill a cop," she said. "They just want to get a bag of chips and relax. Alcohol is a much bigger problem."

That such starkly different views on marijuana would come from two top-ranking police officials is less surprising when you take local context into account. More than 70 percent of D.C. voters said yes to Initiative 71, so it's in Lanier's political interests to seem chill about the changes. Bratton, on the other hand, is trying to get back into the good graces of the police unions following a dust-up between them and the mayor in the wake of the shooting deaths of two NYPD detectives in December.

Bratton's rhetoric has something in common with Lanier's, though, whether he intended it or not. Gawker's Andy Cush hit the nail on the head in a post earlier this week on the commissioner's claims about pot and violent crime:

These aren't stories of overdoses or men driven driven to madness by a bong rip; they're the direct consequences of a culture that sends people to jail for pot. Whether he meant to or not, the commissioner of the NYPD just made a pretty compelling case for ending prohibition.

If we want to end weed-related violence in New York, we have a really simple means of doing so: legalizing it. How many of the city's beer distributors have been murdered this year?

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Design

    Changing Tides Engulf the South Street Seaport

    Mayor Ed Koch wanted a family-friendly attraction for Lower Manhattan. But this 1983 icon of yuppie-era NYC was swept off course by changing tastes.

  2. animated illustration: cars, bikes, scooters and drones in motion.

    This City Was Sick of Tech Disruptors. So It Decided to Become One.

    To rein in traffic-snarling new mobility modes, L.A. needed digital savvy. Then came a privacy uproar, a murky cast of consultants, and a legal crusade by Uber.

  3. photo: Uber and Lyft vehicles.

    Ride-Hailing Isn’t Really Green

    The Union of Concerned Scientists estimates that the environmental impact of Uber and Lyft rides is 69% worse than the transportation modes they replace.

  4. photo: Cranes on the skyline in Oakland, California

    How to Make a Housing Crisis

    The new book Golden Gates details how California set itself up for its current affordability crunch—and how it can now help build a nationwide housing movement.

  5. a photo of a New Orleans pothole

    Here’s a Pothole Stunt for the Ages in New Orleans

    Tired of waiting for the city to fix their street, residents of the Irish Channel neighborhood furnished their pothole and listed it as an Airbnb rental. It worked.