A woman attends a candlelight vigil for Eric Garner on Martin Luther King Day. REUTERS/Carlo Allegri

Including: “The fact that he states eleven times that he can’t breathe proves he was actually breathing.”

Eric Garner was killed by a New York Police Department officer in July, 2014, over the crime of selling loose cigarettes outside a convenience mart in Staten Island. His final words—“I can’t breathe!”—have become an awful mantra for protesters demanding justice in the policing of black communities.

On Monday, New York City reached a $5.9 million settlement in the wrongful death claim filed by Garner’s family, just four days shy of the one-year anniversary of his death.

The settlement prompted a disgusted reply from Ed Mullins, president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association in New York. Mullins called the settlement “obscene” and “shameful” in a column for the New York Post.

“Mr. Garner’s family should not be rewarded simply because he repeatedly chose to break the law and resist arrest,” he writes. (Emphasis added to highlight Mullins’s word choice.)

Pointed and gruesome responses are nothing new for police unions. Baltimore’s police-union chief called peaceful protesters a “lynch mob.” Cleveland’s police-union chief said that the city had “given the inmates the keys to the asylum” in response to protests. Louisville’s police union issued a straight-up threat to residents after critics questioned a police shooting.

But Garner’s death has led to more bloodless hyperboles than any other high-profile police killing of an unarmed man in the last year (of which there have been many). Here is a sampling:  

August 4: “We want justice for everyone except police officers.”
—Ed Mullins, president, Sergeants Benevolent Association (press conference)

August 4: “Sometimes the use of force is necessary. But it's never pretty to watch.” —Patrick Lynch, president, New York City Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association (DNAinfo)

August 4: "What's being left out of everything that's been printed by the media is the fact that police officer [Daniel] Pantaleo didn't go to work that day with the intention of killing anyone.” —Mullins (press conference)

August 4: “The attacks on the NYPD have to stop.” —Mullins (press conference)

August 4: “Police officers deserve to go home at the end of the day in the same shape that they arrive. That's not happening now.” —Lynch (press conference)

December 5, 2014: “Police officers feel like they are being thrown under the bus.” —Lynch (CBS/Associated Press)

December 8, 2014: “The fact that he states eleven times that he can’t breathe proves he was actually breathing.” —Javier Ortiz, president, Miami Fraternal Order of Police Lodge #20 (The Washington Post)

At times, police-union chiefs have of course expressed regret for Garner’s death—but balanced always by the insistence that police were simply doing their jobs.

“Don’t congratulate us. This is not a victory,” said Gwen Carr, Garner’s mother, during a press conference on Tuesday morning. “Victory will come when we get justice.”

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A map showing the affordability of housing in the U.S.
    Equity

    Minimum Wage Still Can’t Pay for a Two-Bedroom Apartment Anywhere

    The 30th anniversary edition of the National Low Income Housing Coalition report, “Out of Reach,” shows that housing affordability is getting worse, not better.

  2. Two men with yellow hard hats surrounded by technology boxes
    Life

    Job Density Is Increasing in Superstar Cities and Sprawling in Others

    A study finds job density increased in the U.S. over a 10-year period. But four cities: New York, Chicago, San Francisco, and Seattle, accounted for most of it.

  3. A photo of a Google employee on a bicycle.
    Equity

    How Far Will Google’s Billion-Dollar Bay Area Housing Plan Go?

    The single largest commitment by a private employer to address the Bay Area’s acute affordable housing crisis is unique in its focus on land redevelopment.

  4. A photo of a cyclist on the streets of Chicago's Pilsen neighborhood.
    Equity

    Can Historic Preservation Cool Down a Hot Neighborhood?

    The new plan to landmark Chicago’s Pilsen neighborhood aims to protect more than just buildings: It’s designed to curb gentrification.

  5. Four young adults exercise in a dark, neon-lit gym.
    Life

    Luxury Gyms Invite You to Work Out, Hang Out, Or Just Work

    With their invite-only policies and coworking spaces, high-end urban gyms aspire to be fitness studio, social club, and office rolled into one.

×