Roman Boed/Flickr

Roughly a year after strict new rent control laws took effect, 30 percent of residential leases have come down in price.

Rent control laws in the city of Paris are doing exactly what they were designed to do. That’s what France’s Minister for Housing, Emmanuelle Cosse, has been saying in recent celebratory interviews to the French media. It’s been roughly a year since France put in place strict restrictions on rent rises in Paris and other “strained zones” across the country. And while it’s Cosse’s job to defend legislation introduced by her government, there is indeed evidence in the past year’s figures to back up the assertion that the law changes are doing their job.

According to figures released by Paris’s Rent Observatory this week, 30 percent of the city’s new residential rental contracts signed over the past year have come in lower than the previous contract for the same properties. For Parisian renters in search of a better deal, that’s certainly good news. Critics of the new law are nonetheless complaining that the drop in monthly rents for new residential leases is uneven and comes with other unwelcome side effects.

France’s current rent law, which went into effect about a year ago and is referred to locally as the Loi Alur (and sometimes the Loi Duflot after the minister who oversaw it) works as follows: In zones of high demand—a.k.a. the cities of Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Montpellier, Ajaccio and Arcachon—all rental contracts are overseen by an official observatory. This observatory estimates and fixes a median rent per square meter for a given area, separating the district’s real estate into price bands based on whether it’s furnished and the number of rooms. No future rental contract is allowed to charge more than 20 percent more than the fixed median rent for the apartment’s price band. This not only (in theory) prevents galloping rent rises, it also provides prospective tenants with a clear marker of how much landlords have the right to charge.

That’s how it is supposed to work, at least. In practice, reports from real estate agents (who opposed the law) suggest that landlords are still getting away with charging too much in some areas. This is because it’s up to tenants to complain, and in certain areas many of them are prepared to pay extra to get the right apartment. Still, even amid reports of overcharging, the overall proportion of overpriced apartments is falling, so the law is clearly having some effect even if informing tenants of their rights has remained an issue.

It’s an issue that a Parisian website launched last week may well help to address. The Encadrement des Loyers website lets both tenants and landlords type in an apartment’s size and location and find out if the rent being asked for a new contract is too high or not. Follow the simple seven-step questionnaire and you leave armed with an accurate assessment of whether or not a residential lease conforms to the new law. This won’t stop tenants who choose to overlook the rental observatory rules to get the right apartment, of course. But the hope is that it will cut the number of tenants accepting rents that are too high simply because they’re uninformed.

Frustrated landlords have nonetheless pointed out some ongoing inconsistencies with the law. France’s National Real Estate Federation has claimed that the criteria offered by the law for judging apartments’ proper rent are too limited. As newspaper Économie Matin noted last month:

“Be aware that only four criteria are used to fix the basic rent (location, building age, number of rooms and being furnished/unfurnished). It’s not the condition of the housing. The basic rent [allowed] is the same if the accommodation is newly refurbished or with shabby paint and dilapidated bathrooms. Similarly, the rent for a 6th floor apartment will be identical with or without an elevator.”

This sounds cumbersome, but suggests problems with fine tuning the regulations rather than with the concept of the law itself. Meanwhile warnings from pro-landlord groups that some owners would simply withdraw their properties from being rented out to avoid the new laws do not seem to have come true. But could it be the case that poor economic performance, rather than legislation, is behind the reduced asking price for many new rental contracts?

Probably not. France and Paris’s recent economic performance is not amazing; the city has suffered from a tourism downturn since last November’s terrorist attacks. Despite this, France’s economy has actually seen modest growth recently and Paris’s economic outlook seems relatively stable, with a growing population meaning demand for housing remains constant. The city’s rental laws may be a blunt instrument when it comes to differentiating between some types of housing, but it an instrument whose effect is nonetheless being felt.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Design

    A New Plan to Correct a Historic Mistake in Pittsburgh

    A Bjarke Ingels Group-led plan from 2015 has given way to a more “practical” design for the Lower Hill District. Concerns over true affordable housing remain.

  2. A photo of a closed street in St. Louis
    Equity

    What’s Behind the Blocked Streets of St. Louis?

    Thanks to an '80s mania for traffic calming, the St. Louis grid is broken by hundreds of car barriers and cul-de-sacs. Critics say it’s time to get rid of them.

  3. A photo of shoppers on University Avenue in East Palo Alto, California, which is flanked by two technology campuses.
    Equity

    An Island of Silicon Valley Affordability Says Yes to More Housing

    East Palo Alto is surrounded by tech riches, but that hasn’t necessarily helped longtime residents, who welcome a state law mandating zoning reform

  4. A crowded room of residents attend a local public forum in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
    Life

    Are Local Politics As Polarized As National? Depends on the Issue.

    Republican or Democrat, even if we battle over national concerns, research finds that in local politics, it seems we can all just get along—most of the time.

  5. Electricians install solar panels on a roof for Arizona Public Service company in Goodyear, Arizona.
    Environment

    A Bottom-Line Case for the Green New Deal: The Jobs Pay More

    A Brookings report finds that jobs in the clean energy, efficiency, and environmental sectors offer higher salaries than the U.S. average.