Justice

Rikers Was Planned as NYC’s Kinder, Gentler Jail. What Happened?

When Rikers Island jails were designed, critics called them “palaces for prisoners.” New York City is planning replacements, but will they be any better?
In 1908, critics called the new model jails being planned for Rikers Island (seen here in an aerial view in 2017) "palaces for prisoners." Now it has the same notoriety as the facility it was built to replace.Mike Segar/Reuters

When confronted with public uproar over New York City’s teeming, deteriorating, and violence-breeding island jails, local government vowed to do better. They promised a new penal institution: This time, however it would be cleaner and safer, an atonement for the sins of the city’s dark carceral past.

Instead, they created the Rikers Island jails.