Reuters

New policy outlines when the San Francisco transit agency can interrupt wireless service in underground stations

Public transit service disruption just got a whole new meaning.

Officials at the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District have adopted a new policy that determines when the agency can disable the antennas that provide cell phone service to its underground stations. The new rules clarify that BART can disrupt cell service to protect public safety and when “there is strong evidence of imminent unlawful activity,” as the San Francisco Chronicle reports.

The policy limits temporary shutdowns to "the most extraordinary circumstances" posing danger to public safety, destruction of BART property or "substantial disruption" of service. It includes two statements suggested by the FCC late Wednesday in response to BART requests for feedback.

The FCC, in a phone call, asked BART's staff to add wording that "recognizes that any interruption of cell phone service poses serious risks to public safety" as well as a section requiring "a determination that the public safety benefits outweigh the public safety risks of an interruption."

It’s all familiar territory for BART, which embroiled itself in controversy in August when it shut down cell service in underground stations in San Francisco to try to prevent communications that were leading to a protest and forced interruption of train service. For three hours on August 11, BART turned off its antennae in an effort to prevent the organizers of the protest from coordinating efforts to stop trains. The protests stemmed from the shooting death of a man by BART police earlier in the summer, which many saw as an extreme use of force.

The new policy outlines when and how the agency can halt service in the future, mainly by focusing on the potential safety concerns that could result from people disrupting trains. Its new rules [PDF] say that cell phone service should be interrupted “only in the most extreme circumstances,” which could include the use of cell phones as “instrumentalities in explosives; to facilitate violent criminal activity or endanger District passengers, employees or other members of the public such as hostage situations; and to facilitate specific plans or attempts to destroy District property or substantially disrupt public transit services.”

In addition to soliciting input from the FCC, BART also received advice from the American Civil Liberties Union on the policy, according to this post from Tech President. But the language remains fairly vague in terms of how these threats are determined. Given the amount of negative attention BART received when it cut cell service in August, it could be expected to use these new powers sparingly. But the mere fact that a public transit agency has an official policy about when to prevent its users from accessing communication networks should, on its face, be concerning.

Photo credit: Robert Galbraith / Reuters

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A photo of shoppers on University Avenue in East Palo Alto, California, which is flanked by two technology campuses.
    Equity

    An Island of Silicon Valley Affordability Says Yes to More Housing

    East Palo Alto is surrounded by tech riches, but that hasn’t necessarily helped longtime residents, who welcome a state law mandating zoning reform

  2. A young girl winces from the sting as she receives the polio vaccine in 1954.
    Life

    How Mandatory Vaccination Fueled the Anti-Vaxxer Movement

    To better understand the controversy over New York’s measles outbreak, you have to go back to the late 19th century.

  3. A crowded room of residents attend a local public forum in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
    Life

    Are Local Politics As Polarized As National? Depends on the Issue.

    Republican or Democrat, even if we battle over national concerns, research finds that in local politics, it seems we can all just get along—most of the time.

  4. Equity

    What the Supreme Court Said About the 2020 Census Citizenship Question

    In oral arguments, conservative justices asked about data science, while liberals asked what the citizenship question was really for.

  5. A group of students talk as one tests a pedal-free bicycle they have built.
    Environment

    How an Ancestor of the Bicycle Relates to Climate Resilience

    Architecture students in Buffalo built their own versions of the "laufmaschine," a proto-bike invented in response to a 19th-century environmental crisis.