Enrollment is declining, and charter schools are the most likely culprit.

The number of students enrolled in private schools has dropped precipitously in the last decade, from 5.3 million children in 2002 to 4.7 million in 2012. In 2005, 10.7 percent of children were in private school; that number fell to 10 percent in 2010.

The knee-jerk reaction to this news is to blame the recession. But according to new research from Stephanie Ewert of the U.S. Census Bureau, the real reason for this shift isn't belt-tightening (in fact, Ewert found that short-term economic highs and lows have very little impact on private school enrollment), but rather the rise of charters, especially in major cities.

Ewert found a significant negative correlation between enrollment trends in charter schools and private schools. In other words, as a city's charter school network expands, enrollment in private schools decline.

Just look at these maps, which show changes in private and charter school enrollment by state. The red states are the ones that experienced both a decline in private school enrollment and an uptick in charter school enrollment. Here's the map for 2008 - 2009:

And here's 2009 - 2010:

This is all the more striking when you account for the fact that many of the states without growing charter school enrollment simply don't have charter school programs.

It's an interesting trend particularly because charter schools are still largely an urban phenomenon. This data appears to be making the case for additional charter school expansion as a way to encourage young families to stay in cities. As Ewert writes: "If parents perceive charter schools as an improvement over regular public schools, they will change from private to charter schools."

Top image: Pressmaster/Shutterstock

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Transportation

    Do Driverless Cars Need Their Own Roads Around Manhattan?

    A concept for AV expressways promises to reduce travel times, but falls into an old trap of car-centric planning.

  2. Transportation

    Trump's $1 Trillion Infrastructure Plan Has New Reason for Skepticism

    A lawsuit now alleges the president’s advisory council was convened illegally.

  3. Equity

    Why Jimmy Carter Believes Housing Is a Basic Human Right

    Richard Florida talks to the former president about housing, Habitat for Humanity, and how government assistance enabled their current success.

  4. A closed and boarded up public school in Chicago

    What Happens When Poor Kids Are Taught Society Is Fair

    A new study finds that the myth of meritocracy can lead disadvantaged adolescents to act out and engage in risky behavior.

  5. Design

    Where Edmonton Goes Next

    The city that hosted this year’s Habitat for Humanity build also wants to create a downtown that attracts people to stay around after the Alberta oil boom has faded.