An unusual argument against Big Brother on city streets.

Surveillance cameras now exist – often unseen – on city streets in the hundreds, mounted over ATMs, from street lights, at the entrances to private apartment buildings and in public parks. Efforts to map them in Manhattan, for example, have counted more than 2,000 such cameras, each adding to an increasingly comprehensive network that is creating – depending on your point of view – either safer streets or a surveillance state.

CityLab 2013
Exploring urban solutions to global challenges
See full coverage

Critics of this increasingly ubiquitous technology argue that so many electronic eyes have become invasive. They violate your privacy. They're redefining what it means to walk through public space. But here is one more novel argument that might cause unconvinced politicians to reconsider the social costs of heightened security: What if surveillance cameras are also bad for creativity and innovation?

This is the argument of Ann Cavoukian, the commissioner of the Office of Information and Privacy in Ontario, Canada. Speaking Tuesday at The Atlantic's CityLab summit on innovation, she argued that heavily surveilled cities are fundamentally incompatible with environments where people have the excess cognitive capacity to be creative. Spend a lot of your time preoccupied by whether anyone is watching you, and what your movements might look like on camera, and you've got that much less mental bandwidth to focus on things like, well, the next really great idea.

"The point," Cavoukian says, "is the focus shifts away from creativity and innovation and risk-taking, which you need for innovative pursuits."

This argument may sound like a stretch. But at least Cavoukian is speaking the language of municipal politicians now making decisions about how many security cameras are enough. Seemingly every city these days is trying to rebuild its economy around these two buzz words: creativity and innovation.

Watch Cavoukian's full comments here:

 

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Transportation

    How Seattle Bucked a National Trend and Got More People to Ride the Bus

    Three experts in three very different positions weigh in on their city’s ridership success.

  2. Equity

    The Side Pittsburgh Doesn't Want You to See

    Pittsburgh filmmaker Chris Ivey has spent over twelve years documenting the lives of the people displaced so that the city can achieve its “cool” status.  

  3. Transportation

    If You Drive Less Than 10,000 Miles a Year, You Probably Shouldn't Own a Car

    Up to one-quarter of all U.S. drivers might be better off using ride-sharing services instead.

  4. Construction workers build affordable housing units.
    Equity

    Why Is 'Affordable' Housing So Expensive to Build?

    As costs keep rising, it’s becoming harder and harder for governments to subsidize projects like they’ve done in the past.

  5. A man sits on a bench in Bangkok.
    Life

    In a Lonely City, Volunteer Listeners Are Here to Help

    “Often, lonely people long to be noticed by another person who says, ‘I see you.’” That’s where Sidewalk Talk comes in.