Board Game Geek/Isaäc Bickërstaf

What’s more disorienting than moving to New York City and having to pick a verb?

Plugging strange words and phrases into blank-filled narratives isn’t just the favorite Friday night occupation of your friends who are obsessed with “Cards Against Humanity.” In fact, the game concept dates back to before Mad Libs, and before even the dawn of the 20th century. Meet “Peter Coddle’s New York,” an 1880s board game that tackled the very modern predicament of the country bumpkin coming to the big city—an experience as ripe for parody then as it is today.

(Board Game Geek/Isaäc Bickërstaf)

The game, manufactured by companies like McLoughlin Brothers and Parker Brothers (the creators of “Monopoly”), came with a few very important bits of paper. A slim pamphlet told the tale of Mr. Coddle’s trip to New York—minus a few vital phrases. Players used cards, printed with strange expressions (“a sloop load of clams,” “the president of the United States,” “a unicorn”) to fill in those blanks.


It’s basically an 1800s ‘Cards Against Humanity,’” Max Temkin, a co-creator of “Cards Against Humanity,” told Atlas Obscura about the game. (Temkin owns a copy.) “The phrases are very 1800s, and there's a lot of double entendres.”

You can play around with the game online here. Hit “refresh” to see Peter Coddle’s trip transformed by a new set of cards. This, for example:

Peter was anxious to see A FLANNEL NIGHTCAP so he took a steamer to New York, and put up at PUNCH AND JUDY. The next morning he bought A WATER BUTT and A HOT POKER, was measured for A SORE HEAD, and encased his feet in A BASEBALL.

becomes this:

Peter was anxious to see A FIERCE BULL-DOG so he took a steamer to New York, and put up at A SENSATION. The next morning he bought ICE FRIED IN BATTER and A DANDY DUDE, was measured for A BLUE MONKEY, and encased his feet in BLUE BEARD.

Peter! Don’t you know that blue beards and baseballs don’t go on feet?

The story ends with poor, confused Mr. Coddle leaving the city and never returning. Given his experiences in a rapidly changing and growing New York, one filled with dazzling new wealth and architecture but also STEWED FIDDLES, A HORRID SPIDER, and A SMALL-MOUTHED CROCKODILE, can we truly blame him?

Nineteenth-century board game, $40-$75, Ebay.

H/t Mental Floss

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. An aerial photo of downtown Miami.

    The Fastest-Growing U.S. Cities Aren’t What You Think

    Looking at the population and job growth of large cities proper, rather than their metro areas, uncovers some surprises.

  2. Smoke from the fires hangs over Brazil.

    Why the Amazon Is on Fire

    The rash of wildfires now consuming the Amazon rainforest can be blamed on a host of human factors, from climate change to deforestation to Brazilian politics.

  3. Graduates react near the end of commencement exercises at Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia, U.S.

    Where Do College Grads Live? The Top and Bottom U.S. Cities

    Even though superstar hubs top the list of the most educated cities, other cities are growing their share at a much faster rate.

  4. Maps

    The Children’s Book Map That Led Me Out of Depression

    As a child, I loved the fantastical lands from The Phantom Tollbooth. As a troubled college student, I used them as a roadmap to self-acceptance.

  5. Fishing boats, with high rises on the banks and a mosque in the distance.

    Will Sea-Level Rise Claim Egypt’s Second-Largest City?

    Al-Max village in Alexandria was ruined by floods in 2015. Yet, despite climate change’s growing threat to the city, critics say it has scarcely been addressed.