A worker stands in a Sam's Club during a 2014 media tour of Walmart Stores Inc.'s annual shareholder meeting. Rick Wilking/Reuters

Researchers and workers point to the company’s chronic understaffing of stores in communities of color.

Daniel Coles, a Walmart worker in Paramount, California, feels it’s impossible for him to do his job well. “Right now we are understaffed big time,” says Coles, who works in a predominantly Latino, working-class community. “Especially at the front end, we don't have enough cashiers to take care of customers, so we have long lines.”

Coles says he faced similar problems at his previous Walmart job in Crenshaw, a majority-black neighborhood in Los Angeles, but had a much better experience at a Walmart in San Bernardino, which he says catered more to middle-class, white customers. “At San Bernardino, we had enough staffing, we weren't really short at all,” says Coles. “We had coverage in every department, so customers respected us because it was a good experience.”

In Coles’s experience, Walmart seemed to prioritize adequate staffing and customer satisfaction far more in white communities. New research suggests that his experience may be shared by Walmart workers in communities of color across the country.

Adam Reich, an assistant* professor of sociology at Columbia University, conducted an analysis of roughly 35,000 Yelp reviews of all of Walmart’s stores nationwide. Among the 2,840 Walmart stores the reviews pertained to, Reich found that the higher the percentage of Black or Latino residents in a zip code, the lower the Yelp reviews were of stores in that area, even when controlling for the area’s average income.

Race seems to drive low reviews more than area income. (Adam Reich, Columbia University)

When Reich analyzed the adjectives in the Yelp reviews used to describe stores, however, he noticed another telling pattern: Much of the ratings’ language seemed to be about store characteristics, rather than racial judgments.

(Adam Reich, Columbia University)

In Walmart stores in predominantly black zip codes, customers were more likely to use words like “worst,” “unorganized,” “nasty,” and “slow” to describe their shopping experiences. In predominantly white zip codes, customers used words like “smaller,” “friendly,” and “clean” to review their stores.

Reich says this evidence, along with interviews his team collected from 89 Walmart workers in Los Angeles, Dallas, Chicago, Cincinnati, and Florida, suggest that Walmart systematically understaffs stores in communities of color, a practice he calls “consumer redlining.” (Walmart did not respond to CityLab inquiries about Reich’s hypothesis.)

But this perceived understaffing may not necessarily be a result of explicit racial animus so much as a natural consequence of Walmart’s business model, which relies on far lower labor costs than its competitors. Since Walmart opens up many stores in areas where consumers already have few shopping options, the chain, Reich argues, has little incentive to invest in labor for these stores, which are often in communities of color.

“When Walmart moves into the South Side of Chicago, it’s not really displacing numerous other businesses,” says Reich. “So it can shortchange investments in staff, and force people to work harder. Consumers don’t have a choice about where they’re shopping.”

Anthony Roberts, an assistant professor of sociology at California State University who has written extensively on Walmart’s urban-expansion attempts in recent years, points out that such staffing decisions are integral to Walmart’s model.

“The company utilizes data from its stores to predict the optimal staffing levels at the local and regional levels. Employee compensation is an important factor in this analysis, because the company's retail model depends on low wages for profitability,” says Roberts in an email to CityLab. “Given the dependence of these communities on Walmart stores, there seems to be very little need to address poor customer satisfaction… .”

This argument resonates with Coles’s experience working with Walmart customers. “Customers [in black and Latino communities] figure it’d be more convenient to not have to travel to Timbuktu to go to another Walmart, or to the ‘right’ neighborhood area because of gas and all that,” says Coles. He notes that the company also conducts “a lot of customer surveys about people's shopping experiences,” which help gauge how much money specific stores bring in—and therefore may influence the number of employees hired.

These labor cost-saving strategies, however, may actually be hurting Walmart’s ability to expand, especially in urban markets with large black and Latino populations. Though Walmart has made inroads in cities like Chicago, Dallas, Houston, Atlanta, and Washington, D.C., it has struggled to break into other major urban centers such as Boston, New York, San Francisco, and Seattle, in large part due to community mobilization and political pressure.

Walmart’s failure to capture its national average market share in the most urban areas has cost it nearly $96 billion dollars a year, according to a 2015 UCLA study by the Institute for Research on Labor and Employment.

“Labor investment is critical for penetrating the urban market, because these communities are most concerned about job prospects in local development,” says Roberts. “If Walmart wants to dramatically break into the urban market, the company needs to address its reputation of creating 'bad jobs' by expanding and investing in its labor force.”

If customers feel the toll of this model of labor investment, Walmart workers in black and Latino communities do, as well. “At Crenshaw, customers would say, ‘Y'all so ghetto. You don't have enough registers, customer service people,’” says Coles. “It was sad to see how the company didn't care about the [workers]. … They are looking at the bottom line, that’s it.”

*CORRECTION: This post has been updated with Adam Reich’s correct title.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A photo of a police officer in El Paso, Texas.

    What New Research Says About Race and Police Shootings

    Two new studies have revived the long-running debate over how police respond to white criminal suspects versus African Americans.

  2. Four New York City police officers arresting a man.

    The Price of Defunding the Police

    A new report fleshes out the controversial demand to cut police department budgets and reallocate those funds into healthcare, housing, jobs, and schools. Will that make communities of color safer?

  3. Equity

    The Problem With Research on Racial Bias and Police Shootings

    Despite new research on police brutality, we still have no idea whether violence toward African Americans is fueled by racial prejudice. That has consequences.

  4. Maps

    Your Maps of Life Under Lockdown

    Stressful commutes, unexpected routines, and emergent wildlife appear in your homemade maps of life during the coronavirus pandemic.

  5. Life

    What the ‘Battle of Seattle’ Means 20 Years Later

    The 1999 WTO protests shut down Seattle and brought new attention to the effects of global trade. The event looms large in the activist imagination today.