A kid with a Mohawk hairdo travels on the subway line number 2 in Shanghai
Who deserves this seat? Carlos Barria/Reuters

Readers (and riders) respond to a recent CityLab essay about who deserves to sit.

When grown-up subway riders hop up from their seats to make space for kids, are we doing the younger riders a disservice? Does cowing to the littlest commuters rob them of the chance to learn how to stand on their own feet, both literally and metaphorically?

They’re questions Stephanie Fairyington posed in a recent op-ed for CityLab, in which she advocated for adults keeping their butts in the seats. Readers had a lot to say.

In the comments, Lisa Schweitzer argued that standing kids could slow the process of disembarking.

“I'm torn between ‘let's socialize kids to use the bus properly’ and ‘they never get out of the way when they stand in the aisle, and that costs us a lot of dwell time’ at bus stops. (Buses in LA have long routes, so seconds per stop really matter.) I get that mom or dad has told them to stay near, but honestly, you get kids hanging off mom right by the door, the kid never moves, the parent never tells them to move, and they ignore you when you ask to get by. And it's always a mess. And if you don't give your seat to a person trying to manage a small baby I am soooooo judging you into the ‘raised by wolves’ category.”

David Forgue wrote that there’s no single standard for assessing who needs to sit:

“You don't ever roll your eyes at someone for not giving up their seat, since just as you may not see their disability, they might not see yours. … Kids should be socialized to ride public transit as soon as practicable, but practicable depends on the kid, the frequency of the ridership, and other factors.”

Meanwhile, another reader noted that some transit systems do have one-size-fits-all rules:

“Students’ bus tickets in Greece are explicitly standing-only.”

On our Facebook page, a reader named Victoria Olausson noted that it might be scary for kids to feel dwarfed by taller riders:

“In a crowded public transport, breathing can be difficult when everybody around you is 50 to 60 cm taller. Not to talk about having people's bags right in your face. In my opinion it is inconsiderate not to let the small ones sit.”

On The Atlantic’s Facebook page, Katelyn Lloyd spoke from the perspective of a mother just looking for a smidgen of empathy:

“My view, generally, is to offer help to, and make concessions for, those who are struggling more than I am. As a single mother who used public transportation daily until recently, I can assure everyone that holding a toddler and a railing on a crowded, rush-hour bus is a hellacious shitstorm, and I greatly appreciated strangers who showed kindness and understanding, whether that meant offering a seat or saying, ‘He's adorable,’ when it was apparent that I was at my wit's end.”

Yesterday, following up on CityLab’s piece, the radio station WNYC posed the question to riders shuttling around the subway.

“It depends on how tired the child looks,” one rider explained to the reporter, Shumita Basu. Other straphangers echoed Fairyington’s tough-love stance. The youngest passengers “need to build up their strength,” one woman argued.

That’s a refrain we saw in our comments section, too, where a reader named Gwinny wrote:

“Nothing is more frustrating than getting on a crowded train during rush hour to find that half the seats are taken by kids looking at screens. They have all the energy in the world, whereas I certainly do not at the end of a long workday.”

Listen to WNYC's story below, and tell us what you think.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Two different Eiffel Towers rise above manicured lawns. The one on the left is an image from Tianducheng, a city in China, and the one on the right is an image from Paris.
    Photos

    Which One Is Paris?

    Francois Prost’s new photo series looks at Tianducheng, a town built to look exactly like the City of Lights.

  2. 1970s apartment complex in downtown Buffalo
    Equity

    The Last Man Standing in a Doomed Buffalo Housing Complex

    After a long fight between tenants and management, John Schmidt is waiting for U.S. Marshals to drag him out of Shoreline apartments, a Brutalist project designed by Paul Rudolph.

  3. Transportation

    How Toronto Turned an Airport Rail Failure Into a Commuter Asset

    The Union Pearson Express launched with expensive rides and low ridership. Now, with fares slashed in half and a light rail connection in the works, it’s a legitimate transit alternative for workers.

  4. A small accessory dwelling unit—known as an ADU—is attached to an older single-family home in a Portland, Oregon, neighborhood.
    Design

    The Granny Flats Are Coming

    A new book argues that the U.S. is about to see more accessory dwelling units and guides homeowners on how to design and build them.

  5. Transportation

    The Automotive Liberation of Paris

    The city has waged a remarkably successful effort to get cars off its streets and reclaim walkable space. But it didn’t happen overnight.