FCC/Casey Miller/Mapbox

Internet users with the fewest options may lose the most from the FCC’s decision.

Net neutrality was probably never enough to keep the internet “free,” even before the Federal Communications Commission voted to repeal it in December.

Already, some 129 million Americans—roughly 40 percent of the population—have only one option for broadband internet service where they live, according to a report by the Institute for Local Self-Reliance. Among them, about 50 million are resigned to using a company that has broken the rules of net neutrality. These are providers that have run afoul of FCC regulations meant to keep web content fairly and equally accessible—they’ve hijacked user search entries, blocked video streaming services, and slowed down peer-to-peer file-sharing, among other offenses. And for Americans who can shop between multiple service providers, 50 million have to choose between just two companies with violations on their records.

Now, with the FCC scrapping Obama-era internet regulations, the users with the most to lose may be the ones who had few options to begin with. See how stark the landscape of non-competition looks: Casey Miller, a data visualization specialist at Mapbox, a mapping software startup based in San Francisco, has mapped every internet service provider and option available for 11 million Census blocks across the U.S.

In denser parts of big cities, it’s easy to find as many as four or five ISP offerings. (Curiously, in downtown Chicago, the diversity of access seems to vary a lot from block to block.) But those options dry up the further you move from urban centers. Most of Columbus, Ohio—which is positioning itself as a tech capital of the Midwest—has to choose between two or three ISPs. It’s worse in Fresno, the seventh-largest city in California. Large swaths of the population are getting unWired broadband or nothing.

Welcome to Fresno. (FCC/Casey Miller/Mapbox)

The data may not be fully up to date, says Miller: The FCC says its files were last updated in November 2017, but there are some locations where available internet services are even fewer than what’s shown here. (The reverse is likely true, too.)

Mapping the FCC data drives home the stakes of the net neutrality debate, Miller said. Millions of people subscribe to whatever choice they have without thinking too much about it, or how it might affect them in the future. “But what that means is, you can’t switch, unless you move,” Miller said. “If you only have one option, you really are at the mercy of your provider.”

What might that mean? According to the many opponents of the FCC’s decision, monopolistic internet service providers could contort the web into a pay-to-play hierarchy of informational access. The agency’s chairman, Ajit Pai, and his supporters insist that ISPs will speed up and expand connections once unburdened of costly regulations.

Reality will most likely land somewhere in between. But many analysts agree that the average internet customer will see payments creep up over time, as service providers “bundle” their own online media properties separately from others and charge premium prices for out-of-network content. (Verizon has acquired Yahoo; Comcast partly owns Hulu; AT&T has special deals with HBO, for example.) And removing regulations is unlikely to encourage new broadband connections in underserved communities—there’s just not enough competition.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. A colorful mural with a woman's head and words reading "take me out to the go-go."
    Equity

    How Go-Go Music Became Kryptonite for Gentrification in D.C.

    Go-go has become the soundtrack for a growing anti-gentrification movement in Washington. Now a city council bill wants to make it D.C.’s official music.

  2. audience members at venue
    Life

    What Early-Career Income Volatility Means for Your Middle-Aged Brain

    A long-term study of people in four cities finds that income volatility in one’s 20s and 30s correlates with negative brain effects in middle age.

  3. Drilling Wells in Los Angeles
    Environment

    Why Is California Approving So Many New Oil Wells?

    Drilling and fracking permits are up since Governor Newsom took office. But it’s not totally clear why.

  4. photo: An elderly resident of a village in Japan's Gunma Prefecture.
    Life

    In Japan’s Vanishing Rural Towns, Newcomers Are Wanted

    Facing declining birthrates and rural depopulation, hundreds of “marginal villages” could vanish in a few decades. But some small towns are fighting back.

  5. Life

    Holland Aims to Bring Back Its Starry Nights

    Campaigners want government agencies and companies to turn off the lights so citizens can rediscover the beauty of darkness.

×