Courtesy of the Moynihan Station Development Corporation

As construction of Moynihan Station moves forward, the rail provider says it can't pay much rent

The shortcomings of New York's Penn Station are clear all year round, but they come into view most painfully during the holiday rush. At the current Penn Station, intercity passengers traveling on Amtrak pack into the same inadequately sized waiting area with New Jersey Transit commuters, hoping to get a jump on the track announcements. Travelers arriving at the station must push through the crowds to reach a street exit or weave through the station's catacombs to find a subway connection. According to a 2010 report by the state of New York [PDF], Penn Station is the "busiest, most congested, passenger transportation facility in North America" on a daily basis — with a greater traffic flow than all three of New York City's airports combined.

The situation is expected to improve considerably with the construction of the new Moynihan Station. The project — named for Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, its original proponent — has been in the works since the early 1990s. Moynihan Station will occupy part of the massive Farley Post Office building just across Eighth Avenue from Penn Station. Once completed the station will be the new intercity rail hub for New York and the fulcrum of travel in the lucrative Northeast Corridor. The only problem is that Amtrak now says it can't afford to leave Penn Station unless it can occupy Moynihan "effectively rent-free," reports Bloomberg.

Moynihan Station is being built in two phases. The first phase will provide better egress for passengers arriving into New York. That phase, which is almost fully funded, began in October of 2010 and is scheduled for completion in 2016. It will certainly alleviate some of the crowding. Right now passengers exit Amtrak trains on platforms below the Farley building but must walk a ways to exit at Penn Station. The first phase will poke 19 direct new access points onto the street level, and "will significantly ameliorate platform and access congestion throughout the Penn Station complex as a whole," according to the 2010 report.

It's the second phase that will result in Amtrak's main passenger facility leaving Penn Station. That phase — still unfunded and expected to cost about $1 billion — would create an impressive new railroad hall and shift all intercity travel into Moynihan Station, separating it entirely from commuter traffic. The station is critical to expanded rail traffic along the Northeast Corridor and would serve as an anchor to high-speed rail travel in the Northeast; at the present time Penn Station is operating over capacity.

But Amtrak can't occupy the new Moynihan Station if the move results in anything but a "modest increase" in operating costs, an Amtrak official told Bloomberg earlier this month. While Amtrak had a record ridership of more than 30 million passengers [PDF] in 2011 — with ridership in the Northeast leading the way — the federally funded passenger service remains on shaky fiscal ground. In fiscal 2010, for instance, Amtrak posted a net loss of roughly $1.3 billion [PDF]. Amtrak also had its 2012 funding cut and saw President Obama's high-speed rail program, through which the Moynihan Station could potentially get financial support, receive no funding at all.

The rent discussion may become moot if officials can't raise the money for the second phase of Moynihan. Some money could come through the Port Authority, which is overseeing the project, but so far other fundraising efforts have fallen flat. In April New York Governor Andrew Cuomo requested about $50 million in federal funding to pay for design plans, but was rejected. 

Images courtesy of the Moynihan Station Development Corporation

About the Author

Eric Jaffe
Eric Jaffe

Eric Jaffe is the former New York bureau chief for CityLab. He is the author of A Curious Madness and The King's Best Highway.

Most Popular

  1. Homeless individuals inside a shelter in Vienna in 2010
    Equity

    How Vienna Solved Homelessness

    What lessons could Seattle draw from their success?

  2. Two New York City subway cars derailed on the A line in Harlem Tuesday, another reminder of the MTA's many problems.
    Transportation

    Overcrowding Is Not the New York Subway's Problem

    Yes, the trains are packed. But don’t blame the victims of the city’s transit meltdown.

  3. Equity

    The Hoarding of the American Dream

    A new book examines how the upper-middle class has enriched itself and harmed economic mobility.

  4. Members of a tenants' organization in East Harlem gather outside the office of landlord developer Dawnay, Day Group, as lawyers attempt to serve the company with court papers on behalf of tenants, during a press conference in New York. The tenant's group, Movement for Justice in El Barrio, filed suit against Dawnay, Day Group, the London-based investment corporation "for harassing tenants by falsely and illegally charging fees in attempts to push immigrant families from their homes and gentrify the neighborhood," said Chaumtoli Huq, an attorney for the tenants.
    Equity

    Toward Being a Better Gentrifier

    There’s a right way and a wrong way to be a neighbor during a time of rapid community change.

  5. Life

    Why a City Block Can Be One of the Loneliest Places on Earth

    Feelings of isolation are common in cities. Let’s take a look at how the built environment plays into that.