The MBTA has opened a competition to the public. And a good thing too - the current map has serious flaws.

You don't have to be a professional designer to point out some of the flaws in Boston's transit map. The five-legged Green line is too cramped to fit all the station names. The Silver line looks like a subway line even though it's a bus rapid transit system. The key local bus lines are great to have, but one suspects they aren't terribly useful to anyone who doesn't already use them.

And the MBTA agrees the map can be improved, because this week it announced a public competition to do just that. From now through the end of April, Boston's transit authority is accepting design submissions on individual aspects of the map as well as complete renderings. Winners will be selected for their creativity, aesthetic presentation, and informative quality, and announced in mid-May as part of National Transportation Week.

Whether the MBTA knows it or not, the authority doesn't have to look far for a good replacement candidate. Cameron Booth, whose previous work has included a fantastic transit-style map of the U.S. Interstate Highway System, created a new Boston transit map back in 2012 (via Universal Hub). He's called the current map "well meaning, but seriously flawed" in more charitable moments, and a "horrible mess" in less diplomatic ones.

Long before the current competition was announced, Booth made several redesigned MBTA maps, some including key bus lines as well as future system expansions. We'll focus on his main map, which includes only subway lines and the BRT:

The first thing that's evident in Booth's redesign is that all the Green line stations are named. (Booth acknowledges these additions can only be achieved by making the map a rectangle instead of a square, which it is at present.) The same goes for all the stations on the Silver line. The five Silver BRT lines are now slimmer, to distinguish them from subway routes, are don't blend together as much as before.

In Booth's map, station names are either flat or placed at an upward 45-degree angle; any other variations, including the looping "Silver line" description, are gone. Weekday-only Blue line segments receive a dotted treatment that's impossible to miss. The colors in general are deeper and the red is now crimson, since it goes through Harvard after all. Stations within walking distance of one another — something that's very rarely apparent on transit maps — are connected with a thin black line.

These improvements give the MBTA map a crisper, cleaner appearance, but Booth won't be submitted his work for the current contest anytime soon. That's not because he isn't up to the challenge (he would need to render the map as a "perfect square" to meet competition guidelines), but because he sees the contest as an unfair means to gather good ideas without compensation. Indeed, submissions become the "sole property" of MBTA, and the transit authority owns the "entire copyright," according to the contest rules.

Writing at his blog earlier this week, Booth called those stipulations "insulting" to designers:

Eventually, I was going to get around to making a square version, but not now. Not now that I know the MBTA is looking for free ideas for their map. If the MBTA likes my ideas for their map — and they’ve surely seen enough of my body of work to know that it’s good — then they can bloody well pay me for it.

The merits and demerits of freelance speculative work can be debated elsewhere. (And perhaps the MBTA would be willing to arrange some compensation for entrants whose work is deemed so excellent that it's incorporated into official maps in the future.) That discussion aside, two things seem certain, as far as Boston's transit map is concerned. First, transit officials recognize it's time for an improvement, and second, there are talented people out there capable of producing one.

Map via Flickr with permission from Cameron Booth.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Two different Eiffel Towers rise above manicured lawns. The one on the left is an image from Tianducheng, a city in China, and the one on the right is an image from Paris.
    Photos

    Which One Is Paris?

    Francois Prost’s new photo series looks at Tianducheng, a town built to look exactly like the City of Lights.

  2. 1970s apartment complex in downtown Buffalo
    Equity

    The Last Man Standing in a Doomed Buffalo Housing Complex

    After a long fight between tenants and management, John Schmidt is waiting for U.S. Marshals to drag him out of Shoreline apartments, a Brutalist project designed by Paul Rudolph.

  3. Transportation

    How Toronto Turned an Airport Rail Failure Into a Commuter Asset

    The Union Pearson Express launched with expensive rides and low ridership. Now, with fares slashed in half and a light rail connection in the works, it’s a legitimate transit alternative for workers.

  4. Transportation

    The Automotive Liberation of Paris

    The city has waged a remarkably successful effort to get cars off its streets and reclaim walkable space. But it didn’t happen overnight.

  5. A small accessory dwelling unit—known as an ADU—is attached to an older single-family home in a Portland, Oregon, neighborhood.
    Design

    The Granny Flats Are Coming

    A new book argues that the U.S. is about to see more accessory dwelling units and guides homeowners on how to design and build them.