"Take It to Make It" flags in Kirkland, Washington. Brett VA/Flickr Creative Commons

More cities are trying to make crossing the street less deadly by handing out low-tech flags. But does this just make walkers seem weird?

Florida is a lousy place to walk. Life-threatening, even. Four of the 10 metro areas where pedestrians are most likely to be killed by drivers are in the Sunshine State, according to rankings released earlier this year by Smart Growth America and the National Complete Streets Coalition.

Fort Lauderdale was one of the cities on that miserable list, and city leaders have said they are committed to improving conditions for people on foot using a number of strategies. One of which is asking them to carry an orange flag when crossing a particularly busy boulevard in the heart of the city.

Fort Lauderdale officials say that they’re putting out the bright orange flags as just one part of a vision of the city’s transportation future [PDF] in which “the pedestrian is first.” They’ve got a long way to go. During a 2012 telephone town meeting, only 10 percent of Fort Lauderdale residents said the city was “very pedestrian friendly,” while 54 percent said it “needs lots of improvement.” Sixty percent of respondents to a survey said they thought more bikeable and walkable streets should be among the city’s top priorities for capital investment.

The flags aren’t costing much, only about $60 for 15 of the orange banners (although some have already been stolen). “The idea of adding the flags was to add another element of safety, and it’s a minimal cost to the city,” Vice Mayor Romney Rogers told the Miami Herald. “It’s all part of the process of changing people’s ideas about transportation.”

But are flags the right way to do that? What message are they really sending?

Pedestrian flags, with their relatively cheap, low-tech appeal, are nothing new. They are reportedly common in Japan, especially around schools. They’ve been deployed by neighborhood activists trying to improve street safety in Hawaii. Kirkland, Washington, has had a flag program since the mid-1990s, which a study found to be “moderately effective.” [PDF]

Berkeley and Seattle both tried the flags, too, before giving them up as a waste of resources. According to Berkeley’s study of the program, “the use of the flags did not have a noticeable effect upon driver behavior,” and many flags were stolen, leading to high replacement costs. (Also, this being Berkeley, “Many of those who picked up the flags used them for purposes other than for which they were intended.”)

Still, people keep trying it. Bridgeport, Connecticut, has a pilot flag program going on. In St. Paul, Minnesota, Macalester College introduced flags near campus recently after two students were hit and severely injured in a crosswalk in May. One car had stopped for them, but another drove through the crossing, critically injuring one of the students.

Those flags are part of a multipronged effort to improve drivers' awareness of the Minnesota law that requires them to stop for people crossing. "You still have to be cautious, but the flags give you one more tool,” a Macalester employee told the Pioneer Press. “Some drivers look at you like you're a lunatic and they blow by you, but the majority of the people stop."

Of course, it only takes one person “blowing by” to kill you.

A recent study of driver behavior in Chicago highlights just how difficult it is to change driver behavior—and offers some insight into strategies that actually work. For four years, Illinois has had a law requiring motorists to stop at a painted crosswalk to let pedestrians cross. But according to an observational study conducted by the advocacy group Active Transportation Alliance, only 18 percent of drivers on average stopped for people on foot in a marked crosswalk.

The story was markedly different, however, at crossings designated by more than just paint. At crosswalks with flashing lights, brick or stone crosswalks, signs, or raised crosswalks, the rate went up to 61 percent. Still depressingly low, and still indicative of a pedestrian-hostile environment. But far better.

What’s more, the street designs that proved effective in Chicago and its suburbs don’t require pedestrians to do something that many might feel is silly—like carrying a flag. They don’t make it seem like crossing the street is an unusual or eccentric thing to do. They weave the protections for the pedestrians into the fabric of the street itself.

Part of the reason drivers in so many parts of the country treat people on foot as if they were invisible is that the streets are designed to keep traffic moving, funneling through the maximum number of cars in the minimum amount of time. More visible crosswalks and other visual cues can help with that part.

But another very important factor is that many people in this country don’t walk very much themselves. They don’t project themselves in the pedestrian’s frame of mind when they’re driving, because they are rarely in the pedestrian’s position at any other time.

In many communities, people traveling by foot are often stigmatized as poor or mentally ill. Expecting people to carry flags so they can cross without getting killed—in the words of Kirkland’s campaign, expecting them to “Take It to Make It”—only increases the sense that being a person on foot is somehow weird or embarrassing. Cities should instead be doing everything they can to advance the radical notion that walking is a perfectly normal thing to do.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Equity

    The Hidden Horror of Hudson Yards Is How It Was Financed

    Manhattan’s new luxury mega-project was partially bankrolled by an investor visa program called EB-5, which was meant to help poverty-stricken areas.

  2. A woman looks straight at camera with others people and trees in background.

    Why Pittsburgh Is the Worst City for Black Women, in 6 Charts

    Pittsburgh is the worst place for black women to live in for just about every indicator of livability, says the city’s Gender Equity Commission.

  3. a photo of a full parking lot with a double rainbow over it

    Parking Reform Will Save the City

    Cities that require builders to provide off-street parking trigger more traffic, sprawl, and housing unaffordability. But we can break the vicious cycle.   

  4. a map comparing the sizes of several cities

    The Commuting Principle That Shaped Urban History

    From ancient Rome to modern Atlanta, the shape of cities has been defined by the technologies that allow commuters to get to work in about 30 minutes.

  5. Life

    How Bad Is It to Let Your Cat Outside?

    Your adorable house cat is also a ruthless predator. A conservation biologist makes the case for keeping cats indoors, or at least on leashes.