Pope Francis's visit to Washington, D.C. on September 23, 2015, didn't lead to crippling traffic. AP Photo/Alex Brandon, Pool

As L.A.’s Carmageddon proved a few years ago, congestion alerts can be extremely effective—until they wear off.

The arrival of Pope Francis into Washington, D.C., was supposed to bring with it ungodly traffic jams. But morning rush came and went in the nation’s capital Wednesday without so much as a hint of the predicted Popemageddon. Metro ridership was down 14 percent on a week ago, and Politico reported major traffic jams were “few and far between”:

"Knock on wood, we're doing OK. We're surviving," said Jim Battagliese, the director of traffic and weather operations for WTOP. "This morning was very light, so it looks like people got the message that things were going to be busy and stayed off the roads."

All due respect to Battagliese, Syrian refugees are surviving. D.C. commuters are responding exactly how recent experience in other cities suggested they would. When Los Angeles faced Carmageddon—the complete shutdown of a 10-mile stretch of Interstate 405 for an entire weekend—a few years back, traffic levels plunged along the freeway and nearby roads, according to an analysis by UC transport scholars Brian Taylor and Martin Wachs. L.A.’s sequel, Carmageddon II, failed to live up to the original, but traffic congestion still dropped significantly then, too.

Access

Carmageddon offered several lessons on predictable traffic jams. One is when Kim Kardashian tweets, people listen. Media hype was a big reason for the congestion decline; Taylor and Wachs write that “disseminating information can also be enormously effective—even more effective than providing alternative travel modes.” Indeed, bus ridership during the first Carmageddon fell, too, despite a bump in service. People stayed home, as per Kim’s orders.

Here’s the thing about traffic: even slight drops or spikes in the number of cars on a road (or, for that matter, slightly poor maneuvers) can have a disproportionate impact on congestion. In the parlance of wonks, traffic is “nonlinear”; as Tom Vanderbilt once explained: “Increase the amount of vehicles by 33 percent and congestion is bound to increase well beyond that.” This is why concepts like congestion pricing work—if just a few people choose other routes or times, then many benefit.

The other big lesson from Carmageddon—and, for that matter, congestion pricing—is that drivers are startlingly quick to detect new traffic patterns. By the time Carmageddon II rolled around, the threats of crippling congestion had worn off a bit, so relatively more people took to the road. In fact, there were “virtually no deviations” from baseline traffic by the end of the second closure. Here’s Taylor and Wachs:

As the event progressed and predictions of Carmageddon failed to materialize, motorists adjusted their behavior in response to more sober media reports and real-time traffic information. Some who had originally planned to avoid driving out of fear of nightmarish congestion likely reverted to their more typical driving behavior by taking highway or arterial detours.

Experts have a name for this, too: induced demand. As more space on a road becomes available, more drivers rush to fill it, sure as the pope’s Catholic. It’s why D.C. might not be out of the woods just yet—and a word to the wise for Philadelphia and New York.

About the Author

Most Popular

  1. Transportation

    With Trains Like Schwebebahn, No Wonder Germans Love Public Transit

    Infrastructure like this makes it clear why Germany continues to produce enthusiasm for public transit, generation after generation.

  2. Transportation

    You Can’t Design Bike-Friendly Cities Without Considering Race and Class

    Bike equity is a powerful tool for reducing inequality. Too often, cycling infrastructure is tailored only to wealthy white cyclists.

  3. Amazon HQ2

    New York’s Ejection of Amazon Is the Start of a Movement

    NYC lawmakers who led a resistance campaign against HQ2 are declaring victory. And already, they have plans to escalate their opposition to tax incentives.

  4. Amazon HQ2

    Amazon’s HQ2 Fiasco Will Cost the Company More Than It Costs New York

    The mega-company has bucked dealing reasonably with New York City, Seattle, and any community that asks them to pay for its freight.

  5. Amazon HQ2

    Without Amazon HQ2, What Happens to Housing in Queens?

    The arrival of the tech company’s new headquarters was set to shake up the borough’s real estate market, driving up rents and spurring displacement. Now what?